upper waypoint
PG&E transmission  towers on the Caribou-Palermo line are seen against a smoky landscape adjacent to the Feather River in Butte County last November. The towers are close to the spot where officials say the Camp Fire began. Josh Edelson/AFP-Getty Images
PG&E transmission towers on the Caribou-Palermo line are seen against a smoky landscape adjacent to the Feather River in Butte County last November. The towers are close to the spot where officials say the Camp Fire began. (Josh Edelson/AFP-Getty Images)

Butte County Is Latest to Take PG&E to Court for Camp Fire

Butte County Is Latest to Take PG&E to Court for Camp Fire

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

Butte County filed suit against PG&E on Tuesday, alleging that the company's failure to respond to extreme weather conditions in the hours before November's Camp Fire played a central role in sparking the catastrophe.

The Nov. 8 fire killed 86 people and destroyed nearly 14,000 homes in and around the town of Paradise, a community the suit describes as "effectively eradicated" by the blaze.

The suit joins dozens of others filed against PG&E in the weeks since the blaze erupted, and like the others alleges that a long history of negligent operations by the utility led to the blaze. Cal Fire investigators are still studying the fire's cause.

The day after the Camp Fire sprang to life, PG&E told state regulators that it had experienced an unexplained outage on the 115-kilovolt Caribou-Palermo transmission line at about the same time and place the blaze was first reported. That initial report indicated an aerial patrol later on the fire's first day found damage to a transmission tower at the ignition site.

Subsequent reports from the company have said further inspections revealed that a broken hook on a transmission tower may have allowed an electrically charged piece of equipment to swing free, causing an electrical arc. A second possible ignition site, about a mile away from the first, involved a broken PG&E pole and downed power lines.

Sponsored

The Butte County suit, filed by County Counsel Bruce Alpert, alleges PG&E failed to adequately maintain its power lines and other equipment, and broke state law by not properly managing vegetation around the lines.

The county's complaint adds that PG&E chose not to shut down electricity flowing through lines in the fire area despite a host of hazardous conditions, including drought, low humidity and tinder-like dry vegetation. Winds in the area where the fire started gusted as high as 52 mph the morning of Nov. 8.

"It is clear that the Camp Fire resulted from PG&E’s willful and conscious disregard of public safety," the lawsuit says.

Alpert, the county counsel, said he filed the suit to "demonstrate to the public that we're moving forward after this horrendous occurrence in Butte County. We're seeking to make the taxpayers of Butte County whole with respect to all of the costs and damages."

The county is seeking damages for repair and replacement of damaged or destroyed property, loss of wages and business profits and more. The lawsuit does not outline a specific monetary amount.

The Butte County suit came one day after PG&E announced it plans to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection at the end of the month. The company says it faces at least $30 billion in wildfire-related liabilities.

Lawyers for the thousands of plaintiffs who have filed actions against the utility -- so far, most of the suits arise from the 2017 North Bay fires, with a growing number coming from Camp Fire victims -- say that the bankruptcy proceeding will likely force a pause in litigation.

PG&E's reorganization under Chapter 11 is also likely to reduce how much plaintiffs will receive if their lawsuits are successful.

PG&E said in a statement Tuesday that safety is its top concern. "We are aware of lawsuits regarding the Camp Fire. Our focus continues to be helping our communities recover and rebuild," spokeswoman Lynsey Paulo said.

This story contains reporting from The Associated Press.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
State Prisons Offset New Inmate Wage Hikes by Cutting Hours for Some WorkersCecil Williams, Legendary Pastor of Glide Church, Dies at 94Erik Aadahl on the Power of Sound in FilmFresno's Chinatown Neighborhood To See Big Changes From High Speed RailKQED Youth Takeover: How Can San Jose Schools Create Safer Campuses?How to Attend a Rally Safely in the Bay Area: Your Rights, Protections and the PoliceWill Less Homework Stress Make California Students Happier?Nurses Warn Patient Safety at Risk as AI Use Spreads in Health CareSilicon Valley House Seat Race Gets a RecountRainn Wilson from ‘The Office’ on Why We Need a Spiritual Revolution