San Francisco Health Plan Employees Cry Foul Over Alleged Retaliation, Executive Pay

Workers for San Francisco’s public healthcare system are demanding more transparency and protections from executives, saying concerns about employee retaliation have gone unaddressed.
San Francisco Health Plan provides Medi-Cal, California’s Medicaid program, for around 130,000 city residents, covering needs including preventive care, specialty care, hospitalization and medications. But employees at the health plan and labor organizers say the system is shrouded in a culture of intimidation and that there is a lack of transparency around executive pay and spending, with little recourse for non-unionized workers alleging retaliatory changes in compensation, work location and schedule.
“San Francisco Health Plan takes employee concerns seriously and is committed to a fair and respectful workplace,” Yolanda R. Richardson, CEO of San Francisco Health Plan, said in a statement. “We are reviewing the issues raised by the San Francisco Labor Council, including our policies and reporting channels.”

San Francisco Health Plan workers, organized under the name SFHP Workers United, have alleged financial misconduct and workplace retaliation against their employer. The San Francisco Labor Council joined them in asking the nonprofit for disclosure of executive compensation, spending on travel and benefits, plus demanding grievance procedures and protections.
“The problem is that the remedies available to them as workers here at the San Francisco Health Plan fall through the cracks,” said Vince Courtney, an executive committee member of the San Francisco Labor Council. “These workers are doing public work and meeting the needs of the poorest of our population, yet they don’t have workers’ rights themselves.”
The labor council adopted a resolution on Oct. 26 urging the San Francisco Health Plan to adopt a grievance procedure by Jan. 1 for its roughly 200 doctors, nurses and administrative workers at the health plan and to notify workers of their rights.
The group is also seeking a binding arbitration procedure and protections against retaliation.
“Employees at SFHP perform work vital to San Francisco’s public health mission, yet they are denied the basic dignity, transparency and protections every worker deserves,” the labor council said in its resolution to leaders.
Labor Council Executive Director Kim Tavaglione called the situation a “unique structural gap” for the hundreds of San Francisco Health Plan employees, who lack certain worker protections compared with public unionized employees in San Francisco.
The San Francisco Labor Council also submitted a public records request to the health plan on Oct. 13 asking how much executives are being paid, how money is spent and how workers can report misconduct. San Francisco Health Plan officials wrote they would respond by Oct. 23, employees said, but so far, they have not received answers to those questions.

“The requested documents would allow scrutiny of executive compensation and expenses,” reads a press release from advocates demanding a response to the workers’ requests. “Their continued withholding leaves workers’ allegations unresolved and basic questions about leadership spending unanswered.”
Richardson said they are currently working with legal counsel to respond to the public records request, adding that the timing was “affected by the need to resolve IT security concerns first.”
A September 2026 audit found that San Francisco Health Plan failed to meet regulatory deadlines to provider disputes, noting that in a review of complaints in November 2025, “none of the 23 post‑payment disputes reviewed were resolved within 45 working days.” The organization claimed the issue was due to attrition in its claims department.
Several city officials have come out supporting the San Francisco Labor Council’s inquiries into San Francisco Health Plan.
“Transparency and accountability are fundamental responsibilities of public-serving institutions, and I urge the health plan to provide a timely response and a clear timeline for producing responsive, nonexempt records,” Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman said in a Nov. 18 letter to Steven Fugaro, chairman of the governing board of the San Francisco Health Plan.

“I stand in support of the workers raising these concerns and encourage you to engage constructively with the San Francisco Labor Council and employees to address the issues identified,” Mandelman wrote.
Assemblymembers Matt Haney, Catherine Stefani and Pilar Schiavo are also backing workers.
“Meaningful progress requires strong oversight and accountability practices, fair and independent processes for employees to raise concerns and clear protections against retaliation,” the three assemblymembers wrote in a Nov. 18 letter to Fugaro. “Independent review of human resources, compliance and whistleblower practices can help identify gaps, address potential conflicts of interest and reinforce public trust.”
Courtney, of the labor council, said that concerns over “exuberant” salaries for executives at the top of the health plan will not be their primary focus as efforts to organize continue.
But he said that the stark pay differences are an “Achilles’ heel” for leadership as they delay agreements with workers for better rights and protections.
“We don’t usually walk away from a fight,” Courtney said. “It’s not over until we win.”
