They bond over the rather banal fact that they were both born on Long Island and the more consequential fact that they vaguely knew one another as children. The art-history major confesses, “I wasn’t the sort of person who yearned to shape a landscape. I wanted only to observe it.” Matthew is intrigued enough to propose, after just a few dates. After she loses her job, he wires a thousand dollars to her bank account each week, no questions asked, and gives her a separate allowance to redecorate their condo. It’s only when they’re about to get married that Lily finds out that Matthew is the scion of a blue-blooded family; he uses a different surname to deflect attention. After they conceive a child via IVF, she discovers a secret connection between Matthew’s parents and her own, which splits the family apart.
The book then skips ahead to 2021 and lodges us in the perspective of Nick, Lily’s son. It’s by far the most plodding and prosaic section, giving us chapter and verse on Nick’s teenage years, college relationships, and eventual employment at a foundation whose “many projects included vaccination campaigns; addressing health inequities; screening against diseases in utero,” and more. The strongest parts are the early years, when we encounter the high-achieving teen fretting over college admissions; his mother wants him to stay close to their home in Seattle, whereas he itches to matriculate at an Ivy League school on the East Coast. “I was self-absorbed without even knowing who I was, or who I should be — an exasperating combination,” he self-mockingly notes. Long estranged from Matthew, Lily raised Nick to understand that his father wanted nothing to do with him. When Nick finally does meet his father — after doing a DNA test — his life takes a fairly predictable turn. Money is an open sesame, unlocking doors to the most prestigious universities, secret societies, and jobs. But the accumulation of it turns Nick into an automaton.
The third and most memorable part of the book is told largely from the perspective of May, Nick’s maternal grandmother. It opens in 2030 with a now octogenarian May trailing her grandson, who works at a “biotechnology startup.” Nick had been led to believe — once again by his mother — that his grandmother had died years ago, but after bumping into each other in a drugstore, they slowly form a friendship and she unfurls the story of her life.