upper waypoint

Alameda County DA Pamela Price Concedes Recall Defeat After Long Holdout

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

A middle-aged Black woman in a suit jacket speaks at a podium, with a 'Alameda County District Attorney's Office banner behind her.
Alameda County District Attorney Pamela Price speaks to reporters during a briefing in Oakland on Oct. 21, 2024. (Beth LaBerge/KQED)

Alameda County District Attorney Pamela Price conceded her recall election on Monday, speaking publicly about the results for the first time since Election Day and accepting a defeat that had appeared all but certain for over a week.

More than 63% of Alameda County voters chose to remove her from office just two years into her term. The Associated Press called the race on Nov. 8, when the pro-recall vote hovered around 65%, but Price remained defiant as she urged supporters to await fuller results.

Price’s recall comes amid a slew of election outcomes that show Californians turning against progressive criminal justice measures and candidates that won in recent years. Price told supporters, though, that the fight for change isn’t over.

Sponsored

“It is up to you and me to make sure that future leaders of this office remain independent decision makers and stay the course of holding public officials accountable and law enforcement officers accountable for their actions,” she said Monday, flanked by more than a dozen supporters, some donning her original 2022 campaign shirts. “Our challenges are too great to be divided.”

Price’s ouster comes just two years after San Francisco recalled its progressive district attorney, Chesa Boudin, and as Oakland voters recalled Mayor Sheng Thao. Statewide, voters overwhelmingly passed Proposition 36, which rolls back lower penalties for certain petty theft and drug possession crimes that voters had passed a decade ago.

During the somber press conference, Price spoke about her administration’s efforts to push forward reform during its two years. Under Price, the Alameda County district attorney’s office secured its first-ever indictment against a corporate polluter in connection to a toxic fire last year. She also touted the creation of a public accountability unit to review cases of police misconduct and an investigation into past administrations’ practice of excluding Black and Jewish jurors from death penalty cases.

“In November of 2022, Alameda County took a huge step forward toward a better criminal legal system,” she told reporters. “In January of 2023, I took office, and since then, I’ve fought to bring change and help to a broken criminal justice system. Under my leadership as district attorney, we made incredible strides towards serving the victims in this county.”

During her tenure, Price faced scrutiny for allowing the statute of limitations to expire on at least hundreds of misdemeanor cases. She also recently came under fire after her office missed the deadline to charge two officers in the death of Mario Gonzalez, an unarmed man who died after being pinned to the ground by police in 2021. His was one of the cases her office reopened under the new accountability unit.

The Rev. Laurie Manning of Skyline Community Church and Jean Moses, a representative of the Interfaith Coalition for Justice in our Jails, spoke about Price’s work to bring charges against Santa Rita Jail staffers accused of negligence that led to the death of an inmate, Maurice Monk, in 2021. They applauded Price’s commitment to exposing a pattern of misconduct and cover-up at the infamously dangerous jail.

Chief Assistant District Attorney Royl Roberts will take over as interim district attorney when the election results are certified, which will happen sometime before Dec. 5. He will serve while the Board of Supervisors works to select a replacement to serve until 2026 when voters will elect a district attorney to serve out the remainder of Price’s term — which had been set for a longer-than-usual six years to align district attorney elections with the presidential cycle.

“Going forward, we are hoping that the Board of Supervisors really weighs what is going to be needed to get the department on the level of functionality because right now it is not,” recall organizer Brenda Grisham said, adding that she and the other leaders of the recall campaign would be weighing in on the selection, but that the decision would ultimately be up to the board.

“I do wish her well in whatever her next position is,” Grisham told KQED.

Price said her team is “working internally to ensure a smooth transition and with the responsible county officials to provide my successor with as much information as possible.”

“I appreciate the opportunity to serve my community and to have made history in Alameda County, and I leave this office in a much better place than how we found it,” she said.

lower waypoint
next waypoint