But he became notorious for aggressive behavior. In the '90s, he was implicated in two deaths: a trainer who drowned, and a man who was found dead in his tank.
Then, in 2010, he killed SeaWorld trainer Dawn Brancheau, holding her underwater until she died of drowning and blunt force trauma.
In the immediate aftermath of that incident, the question was whether Tilikum would be put down, or whether he would return to performing, which he did in 2011.
But then a 2013 documentary called Blackfish changed the narrative around aggressive behavior by orcas, and by Tilikum in particular.
In the film, former trainers at SeaWorld criticized the park's practices as harmful for orcas and dangerous for trainers. They argued that animals such as Tilikum behaved aggressively because of the stress and trauma of captivity.
As NPR's Greg Allen reports, animal welfare groups have long protested against marine parks holding killer whales in captivity at all. When Blackfish came out — and aired on CNN, where it reached millions of viewers — the public joined in the outcry.
The park has denied allegations that it mistreated orcas, but it did shift its position on captive breeding.
Allen reports:
"Orcas are an intelligent, social species that spend much of their life in family groups and in the wild range over thousands of miles. Advocates say holding these huge mammals in a tank is cruel. ...
"Activists stepped up their campaign against SeaWorld following the release of Blackfish. Attendance dropped at the park, a decline the company attributed in part to public reaction to the film. In response, SeaWorld's new CEO Joel Manby announced the company was ending its orca breeding program — making this the last generation of killer whales at its parks.
... Following SeaWorld's decision to end its orca breeding program, [Jeffrey] Ventre and three other former SeaWorld trainers issued a statement. 'We'd like to send love to Tilikum,' they wrote. 'In the end, his message was heard.' "
Members of the public and former SeaWorld trainers also called for Tilikum to be released back into the wild, but SeaWorld says its captive orcas could not survive in the open sea.
Tim Zimmerman, who wrote about Brancheau's death in Outside magazine and was a producer on Blackfish, told Greg there was a deep well of public sympathy for Tilikum.
"I think that's the most amazing thing that comes out of Tilikum's story," he said. "He killed three human beings. And yet when you learn about his life story, he does become the victim and you do sympathize with him."
Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.